What will you do to address speeding on Carlson? Whatโs your stance on public safety? And what about the proposed housing development at the toxic Zeneca site?
Voters gathered to ask candidates running for Richmond City Council District 5 those questions and more Tuesday during a meet-the-candidates night co-hosted by Richmondside, UC Berkeleyโs Richmond Confidential, Contra Costa Pulse and El Tรญmpano. It was the third and final event in a series of council candidate forums in each district. The two previous events were held in district 1 and district 6.
About 50 residents attended Tuesdayโs forum at Easter Hill United Methodist Church, while another 25 tuned in on Zoom to hear from the candidates, Ahmad Anderson and Sue Wilson. (Watch a full recording of the town hall on our YouTube channel.)
Richmond City Council District 5 meet-the-candidates night
WHAT: The District 5 meet-the-candidates night was the final of three Richmondside co-hosted election events. (District 1 was held Sept. 18. Read our recap and watch the video on YouTube. District 6 was on Sept. 30. Read our story and watch the video on YouTube.)
MORE INFO: Not sure which district you live in? Visit Richmondโs city voting district map. For information on voting, read our Contra Costa County how-to-vote guide. And please see our full local elections guide for more.
District 5 is comprised of various neighborhoods along the cityโs southern portion including Marina Bay, the Richmond Annex, Eastshore, Cortez/Stege, the Panhandle Annex, Parkview, Laurel Park and Southwest Annex.
Earlier this summer, the incumbent District 5 council member and former mayor Gayle McLaughlin announced that she would not be seeking reelection, while endorsing fellow Richmond Progressive Alliance member Wilson for her seat.
Wilson, who was born and raised in Detroit, moved to the Bay Area in the late โ90s while working on her doctorate at UC Berkeley and bought a home in the late 2000s in the Richmond Annex neighborhood. She joined the RPA in the early 2010s and has worked on various campaigns related to labor unions, affordable rent and environment protections.
Anderson, a lifelong Richmond resident whose parents both served terms as mayor, is making his third run for office and second to win a seat on the council. He ran for District 5 in 2020 but lost to McLaughlin, and ran for a spot on the BART board.
Each candidate was given two minutes to introduce themselves before moderator Kari Hulac, Richmondsideโs editor-in-chief, presented questions submitted by Richmond residents and compiled by journalists from each co-hosting publication.

During his introduction, Anderson spoke about his ties to local Richmond organizations and his experience working on the cityโs Economic Development Commission.
โLiving here all my life is one thing, but I’ve proven and demonstrated my leadership by being involved not just in District 5, but throughout the city,โ he said.
Wilson pointed to her endorsements, most notably including all of the current RPA-endorsed council members, Contra Costa Supervisor John Gioia, and unions and local nonprofits dedicated to affordable housing and the environment.
โThey trust meโฆ on the issues that matter to Richmond most,โ she said.
Different views on public safety and budget priorities
In the weeks leading up to the town hall, Richmondside interviewed D5 residents who said that safer streets and crime were two of their main issues, so several of the questions asked centered on those themes.
When asked if she would pledge support for police, Wilson answered that her view on reducing crime is โholisticโ and that police, though part of the solution, arenโt the only answer.

โWhat I pledge is that I’m going to put my attention and city resources into pursuing more and varied plans to reduce crime and increase public safety. Just to reassure people, the police are part of that. Right now, the cityโs police take between 35 to 40% of our budget every year, and it’s expensive,โ she said. โWe need to supplement their activities with other sorts of city workers who are focused on making the city a safer place for everyone.โ
She pushed back on the notion that the Richmond police were defunded in 2021, adding that the $3 million reallocated from unfilled police department positions to fund the Reimagining Public Safety Task Force recommendations was miniscule compared to the entire police budget.
โA $3 million cut on a $65 million budget is not defunding,โ she added. โIt’s prudent financial budget balancing โ activities that happen to every department and city every year, police shouldn’t be an exception to that oversight.โ
Wilson said the cityโs recent $550 million settlement with Chevron can begin to address some of the lacking services that residents have historically experienced โ whether code enforcement, illegal dumping or increasing the number of street cameras to monitor and aid in sideshow investigations.
โThe city in the past has been pretty tragically underfunded in these departments, (so) that we don’t have enough people going out to enforce and investigate and make sure that these problems are taken care of,โ she said. โPart of that tax money needs to go to improving city services, including code enforcement.โ (During the forum Wilson on several occasions referred to the Chevron settlement money as a โtax,โ which it is not.)
Responding to a question about sideshows, Anderson said the reduced number of police officers is one reason why theyโve increased in recent years after the pandemic.
According to Richmond Police Department dispatch report data analyzed by Richmondside, sideshow incidents within the city have dropped nearly 50% in recent years โ from 129 in 2022 to 65 in 2023.
He pointed to a July 2023 council meeting where he said a discussion on sideshow enforcement was tabled.
โWhat we did that July was the mayor abstained from voting and stated that there are probably more senior citizens that drive faster on the street than the sideshows,โ he said. While technology could help police track sideshow participants, he added, the police donโt currently have the bandwidth for follow-ups or investigations.
Anderson emphasized economic development throughout the evening and said public safety is intertwined with issues such as blight and homelessness.
โYou need to show folks that you’re willing to support the small businesses, that you’re willing to help folks move from the unhoused areas to jobs, and be able to show that police are available who will mind your streets and be able to look after them,โ he said.
Anderson commended the $550 million Chevron settlement but said itโs not a sustainable way for the city to address its budget problems.
โEconomic development is the engine to providing tax revenue and staffing,โ he said. โThat staffing cannot just hope and wish that what we now receive from Chevron will be the end all. There needs to be implementation, administration and clarity as to where that money will go.โ
Carlson Boulevard ‘death trap’ a major concern

One Zoom viewer asked the candidates how they would handle traffic safety issues on Carlson Boulevard, which includes several of 18 dangerous intersections identified by the city as being a high priority.
At a June 4 meeting, the City Council unanimously approved creating a new two-person Traffic Calming division of the Department of Public Works to help address pedestrian and bicycle safety concerns around the city.
But both candidates agreed that more needs to be done in District 5 โ especially on Carlson.
โI don’t think that the orange flags are working. They haven’t been working,โ Anderson said about the flags installed by residents to help pedestrians make themselves more visible to drivers. โWe tried to collaborate with the city of El Cerrito to cut back on the trees there in that area, because you can’t see, and so you’re actually edging out onto the streets there.โ
Anderson, however, critiqued the cityโs slow approach to the issue, saying that residents have been raising it for a number of years.
โThis has been a discussion in 2020 and still nothing is done,โ he said, adding that reports of accidents in the area are frequent. โThere needs to probably be another light between Central (Avenue) and right at the freeway there up to the offramp. There needs to be a slowdown.โ
Wilson said that as a resident of Richmond Annex not far from Carlson, she has heard of three car-related deaths in the last year.
โItโs a death trap,โ she said, adding that it is the top issue residents have voiced to her. โWe need to do better.โ
Engineering options that the city could possibly look at for Carlson, she said, include making it a one-lane road and installing a bike lane.
โSan Pablo is not terrifyingโ by comparison, she said. โCarlson, just the design of it, it’s a highway.โ
Anderson asked about stance on toxic Zeneca site

A mildly contentious portion of the event happened after Richmond resident Joe Puleo asked Anderson why he supported a developerโs 2020 plan to build housing on the Zeneca site.
The area, which contains vast quantities of contaminated soil, laced with arsenic, uranium, mercury, DDT and many other chemicals, is a result of more than a century of manufacturing, first by Stauffer Chemical and later Zeneca (today AstraZeneca), the pharmaceutical giant.
โWhy did you support putting 10,000 people on a toxic waste site?โ Puleo asked.
โAs an economic development commissioner, I did not support that,โ Anderson replied. โIn fact, I used to play on that site when they actually did the testing of agricultural products. I’m asthmatic today. I lived in that community where most of the folks I know grew up. I would not support that. I’ve never supported building on that site, in that area, on toxic waste.โ
During her reply, Wilson referenced two public comments made by Anderson in 2020 voicing his support for the development plan, which had a $22 million community benefits agreement attached that would provide the city and many nonprofits with funds.

โOn the other hand, I have consistently since 2020 opposed the plan to cap and build on the AstraZeneca site,โ she said. โAs a city council, we need to revisit that plan and really push for a full cleanup of that site. We also have to ask serious questions about, even once it’s clean, whether we should be building thousands of units of new housing that close to the water, given sea level rise.โ
Anderson then clarified that while he did voice support for the development with the community benefits plan included, it was under the condition that the site would be fully cleaned.
โI spoke at length about it in 2020, absolutely,โ Anderson said. โBut today, I would not (support it). I want to be very clear, that was part of the statement, but not the entire statement.โ

we don’t need more ‘traffic calming’ and speed bumps. we need enforcement of laws, and that requires a fully staffed PD. I am on year 6 of attempted recovery, and 4th major surgery coming up, after being totaled head on at 80 on ramp by one of the many NOT law-abiding drivers, many not licensed. they installed speed bumps on S 55th and it is a wonderful new twist for donut spinners and car thieves; every intersection between humps is heavily marked by copious shredded tires and blackened treads. NOT THE ANSWER. boys on illegal dirt bikes enjoy jumping over them while they speed the wrong way against traffic. come on, you can’t put mini mountains all over every street! without enforcement, it is a stupid, wasted effort, and judging by the deep slices into pavement, a fun exercise in transmission destruction and suspension. NEW IDEAS, fully staffed RPD and services. PERIOD>