seven candidates for richmond city council pose for a photo at city hall
All seven candidates for Richmond City Council are shown here at a League of Women Voters candidates forum, but on Oct. 2, the three who are endorsed by the Richmond Progressive Alliance, Claudia Jimenez (center), Melvin Willis (at Jimenez' right) and Sue Wilson (second from right) declined to participate in a Chamber of Commerce forum, saying they felt the event would be biased against them. Credit: Andrew Whitmore

During a Richmond City Council election forum hosted last week by the Richmond Chamber of Commerce the candidates who attended all were critical of the cityโ€™s current elected leaders to varying degrees.

Taking his usual combative tone, District 1 candidate Mark Wassberg called current city council members โ€œa bunch of anarchistsโ€ who โ€œwant to turn Richmond into a welfare city.โ€

District 6 candidate Shawn Dunning, who works in conflict resolution, was more diplomatic.

โ€œWe have one of the most diverse and fascinating cities in the entire country,โ€ Dunning said. โ€œBut we donโ€™t have leaders that are listening to all of the voices here. I donโ€™t want to demonize them, but I canโ€™t help but call out the fact that tonight, virtually all of our opponents are missing.โ€

Incumbent candidates Melvin Willis, District 1, and Claudia Jimenez, District 6, as well as District 5 candidate Sue Wilson, did not attend. They all told Richmondside the main reason they didnโ€™t go was because they thought Wednesdayโ€™s forum, held at Riggerโ€™s Loft Wine Bar, would be biased. 

Jimenez, Willis and Wilson are all endorsed by the Richmond Progressive Alliance and said that the chamber runs the Richmond Business Political Action Committee, often abbreviated as RichPAC, which has supported, and is currently supporting, opponents of RPA-backed candidates. RichPAC spent more than $27,000 in 2022 backing RPA opponents in the City Council and mayoral elections, according to campaign finance filings.

Chamber CEO James Lee said the chamber is a nonprofit that โ€œdoesnโ€™t endorse a candidate or advertise for one,โ€ and that it organized the forum โ€œso that the business community could hear different candidates’ answers to issues our business community faces in Richmond.โ€ 

RichPAC is listed on the chamberโ€™s website where it states that RichPAC โ€œoperates independently of the Richmond Chamber of Commerce.โ€ Campaign filings show Lee is one of the two principal officers for RichPAC. District 5 candidate Anderson is listed as the other one. John Ziesenhenne, a chamber board member, is listed as treasurer of RichPAC. 

In 2022, Lee told the Chevron-funded publication The Richmond Standard that the chamber launched RichPAC to elect pro-business candidates. The move prompted then mayoral candidate and current Mayor Eduardo Martinez to not attend a forum the chamber hosted that year, saying it would not โ€œmeet a minimum standard of fairness,โ€ as RichPAC was then raising money for his opponent Nate Bates. 

Campaign filings show that RichPAC has raised $5,000 this year but donโ€™t show any spending yet. However, the data thatโ€™s reported isnโ€™t fully up-to-date. Willis, Jimenez, and Wilson all said theyโ€™ve seen RichPAC-funded billboards around Richmond in recent weeks in support of Brown, Dunning and Anderson. Richmondside spotted one such billboard supporting Dunning on San Pablo and Solano avenues, and was sent a photo of another supporting Anderson on Cutting and Carlson boulevards.

This billboard at San Pablo and Solano avenues, is among several seen around town supporting Richmond City Council candidates
who are not backed by the Richmond Progressive Alliance. The billboards are paid for by the Richmond Business Political Action Committee.
Credit: Joel Umanzor

โ€œI am not afraid of community forums,โ€ Jimenez told Richmondside (she and her opponent Dunning attended one hosted by the League of Women voters and one co-hosted by Richmondside on Sept. 30). โ€œBut we cannot send people to forums where the playing fields are not even. The Chamber of Commerce is clearly and openly supporting opponents of my campaign.โ€

Jimenez also said she had a date conflict as sheโ€™s the council liaison for the Community Police Review Commission, which met the same night. Additionally, Riggers Loft is currently suing the city, and she said she would have had limitations as to what she could have said about the venue.

In total, about 25 people, including the candidates and the host, Robert Rogers. attended the forum, which primarily was publicized to chamber members via email.

Business taxes, smoke shops among discussion topics

From left: District 1 Richmond City Council candidates Mark Wassberg and Jamelia Brown join District 6 candidate Shawn Dunning (second from right) and District 5 candidate Ahmad Anderson at a Richmond Chamber of Commerce election forum held on Oct. 2, 2024 at Rigger’s Loft. None of their opponents participated, saying they felt the Chamber was biased against them because it’s hosting a web page for a political action committee that doesn’t support them. Credit: Zack Haber

Rogers, who told Richmondside he was hosting in a volunteer capacity, is District Coordinator for Contra Costa County District 1 Supervisor John Gioia. In the rapid-paced hour-long forum, Rogers asked candidates about business, policing, homelessness, and the environment. But he started out by asking them general questions about themselves and why they were running.

District 5 candidate Anderson, who was born and raised in Richmond and whose parents both served as mayors, described himself as โ€œRichmondโ€™s native son.โ€ Speaking in the third person, Anderson said, โ€œAhmad Anderson has paved the way for himself and is really looking to add to the change we need to diversity in leadership” because current leadership โ€œdoesnโ€™t listen to the peopleโ€ and is not concerned with โ€œeconomic development that impacts safety.โ€

District 6 candidate Brown, a fourth-generation Richmond resident, said she โ€œaspires to see Richmond become even more thriving than it once wasโ€ and that she is prioritizing โ€œsafety, engagement, and economic resilience.โ€ To support economic resilience and โ€œa flourishing business community,โ€ Brown said sheโ€™d โ€œstreamline permitting and licensing processes to eliminate red tape that hinders growth.โ€

Dunning said his 25 years of experience in conflict resolution services would help him as a council member.

โ€œItโ€™s about getting people to work well together, build relationships, and more than anything just connecting with people,โ€ said Dunning. 

He said heโ€™s brought the spirit of building relationships to his campaign by walking more than 240 miles so far to meet constituents.

Wassberg, who grew up in San Pablo and worked as an auto mechanic, and also as pipe fitter for Chevron, said he wants a โ€œbig change on the city councilโ€ and that welcoming large corporations is key to achieving positive change.

โ€œMy goal is to bring in big business and to train people for jobs,โ€ Wassberg said. โ€œThe more people who work, the less crime you have and the less homeless.โ€

Early in the forum, Rogers asked several questions about businesses in Richmond. In November 2020 voters approved Measure U, which, after being implemented in January 2022, switched Richmondโ€™s business tax structure from being based on total employees to one based on the total amount of money a business takes in, or gross receipts. Rogers said the tax has increased taxes for businesses and asked what candidates would do to ease tax burdens for businesses while safeguarding the cityโ€™s finances.

Wassberg responded by saying city leadership wants big business out of Richmond and criticized the council for accepting $550 million over a 10-year period from Chevron in exchange for taking a refinery tax on the corporation off of the November ballot. He called the move โ€œblackmail.โ€

Wassberg said, โ€œYou want to tax businesses fairly, but you canโ€™t gouge them because no business is going to want to come to Richmond,โ€ and that Richmond should โ€œgive big businesses a tax break.โ€

Brown said she was โ€œin the middle when it came to Measure Uโ€ because it increased and improved city services, but it was โ€œharmful to businesses overall and to our local economy.โ€ Saying sheโ€™s weary of relying on business taxes to solve fiscal issues at the city level, Brown asked, โ€œWhat are we doing to generate new tax revenue and how are we inviting new businesses and making Richmond more attractive to them and not put on alert?โ€

Dunning said that he isnโ€™t against a shift in tax structure but said the tax rates โ€œneed to be reasonable and make sense.โ€ Richmondโ€™s business tax is currently between .075% and 1.395%. The tax rate, according to Dunning, makes it harder for car dealerships, specifically, to operate. 

Dunning said the new tax rate caused a car dealership’s taxes to rise from $14,000 to more than $1 million and suggested the only way such an increase madeย sense was if the goal was to drive carย dealershipsย out of town. In 2022, six car dealerships in the Hilltop neighborhood owned by the same people sued the city after their taxes cumulatively increased from about $14,000 to about $1.1 million after the new tax took effect, according toย the complaint. In response, the cityย agreed to lower its taxes in response.

Anderson said that when Measure U passed he served on the cityโ€™s Economic Development Commission and said the city wasnโ€™t responsive when the commission asked what level of funds the new Measure U tax would bring in. Anderson criticized the tax and said that a business could operate in bordering cities and โ€œdo better and fair better.โ€

โ€œWe need better leaders,โ€ said Anderson. โ€œOr those leaders up there need finance for dummies.โ€

While all the candidates at the forum questioned whether taxes the city has imposed on businesses recently need to remain at their current level, they didnโ€™t extend open arms to just any business. All were critical of smoke shops โ€” businesses that have long been controversial in Richmond. In April, the council imposed a 45-day moratorium, which has since been renewed, on granting business licenses to new tobacco retailers. At the time, Mayor Eduardo Martinez said that 78 licensed smoke shops were operating, but that additional ones were operating without a license.

โ€œYou have to have businesses that are responsible to the community,โ€ said Anderson, citing the high rates of asthma in Richmond and the dangers of secondhand smoke.

Brown said she was โ€œhappy about the moratorium because thatโ€™s all you see when you come to District 1.โ€

Wassberg said the city should shut down existing smoke shops using its public nuisance law.

โ€œThe smoke shops need to go,โ€ said Wassberg. โ€œAll you see is a bunch of thugs hanging around them.โ€

Dunning said he supported the moratorium on new smoke shops and a ban the city passed on selling flavored tobacco but said the bans arenโ€™t being enforced.

โ€œWhat good are all these rules if weโ€™re not practically enforcing them?โ€ Dunning asked.

According to Dunning, cuts to the police department have hindered policeโ€™s ability to enforce such laws. 

Candidates debate police funding levels

Richmondโ€™s Police Departmentโ€™s budget, which was about $67.5 million in 2020, or about $82.1 million in todayโ€™s dollars when adjusted for inflation, was cut by about $2.3 million in 2021, then cut by an additional $1 million in 2022. Since then, the budget has increased annually. The proposed police budget for 2025 is about $87.2 million.

All of the candidates said they want to expand Richmondโ€™s police force.

โ€œDefunding the police is a nonstarter for me,โ€ said Anderson, who wants more money put into policing.

Brown said that while some areas of Richmond might be safe, she doesnโ€™t feel safe letting her child go to the bus stop alone in District 1. She said that she wants the city to ask the police chief what is needed and collaborate with her to make the community safer. Dunning said that he hears โ€œagain and again that people donโ€™t feel safe in Richmond.โ€

The number of crimes reported in most categories has stayed about the same since 2021, according Richmond Police statistics, with decreases in homicides and assaults citywide decreasing, while vehicle thefts have increased. Anderson said he thinks many crimes go unreported, because people think police lack the resources to respond.

โ€œThe only reason crimes have gone down is people donโ€™t report them,โ€ Anderson said.

Both Dunning and Brown agreed that relationships between police and the community need to be improved. While Brown wants a higher police presence, she expressed concern that officers often drive through her neighborhood with their windows up. Dunning said he wants to return to a community policing model from the mid-2010s that former chief Chris Magus spearheaded.

Wassberg falsely said that after the George Floyd protests, โ€œJust about every democratic city defunded the police,โ€ that the police were also defunded at the federal level, and that presidential candidate and Vice President Kamala Harris said police were unnecessary. He blamed โ€œantifaโ€ and โ€œBlack Lives Matterโ€ and โ€œradicalsโ€ for causing departments to be defunded.

Wassberg supports expanding the police force and said more police are needed than ever.

Wassberg’s comments likening Black Lives Matter activists to radicals sparked the only moment of tense disagreement during the forum. Anderson said he comes from a family that protested during the civil rights movement and if he closes his eyes, he canโ€™t tell the difference between the two groups.

โ€œBlack lives matter,โ€ said Anderson while staring directly at Wassberg. โ€œAs all of our lives matter.โ€

Wassberg attempted to respond to Anderson, but Rogers talked over him, and moved the forum on.

When asked about his approach to homelessness in Richmond, Anderson said thereโ€™s not enough work done to properly tally the number of unhoused people living in the city. Anderson also said he thinks homeless people have a wide variety of abilities and needs and that a one-size-fits-all solution wonโ€™t work.

โ€œWe need to address the type of housing and wrap-around services each person needs,โ€ Anderson said.

Anderson pointed to homelessness as a nationwide and regional issue that requires collaboration. 

โ€œIf we push people out of one neighborhood, theyโ€™ll go to another,โ€ said Anderson. โ€œSo you need to work collectively. Richmond has generally not been part of that collaboration.โ€

Anderson also said that when the city funds agencies that address homelessness, such as Safe Organized Space Richmond, the city needs to see results before giving out more money.

Dunning said that while homelessness is a tough issue one city can help if it collaborates. 

โ€œA city can make a difference, but we have to collaborate to do it,โ€ Dunning said.

He praised the way the city of San Antonio, Texas, collaborated with a Valero Energy Corporation CEO in 2005 to tackle its homelessness issues, reportedly resulting in an 80% decrease in homelessness. According to an article in the San Antonio Express, the number of homeless people statistically recorded in San Antonio fluctuated between 2005 and 2014, depending how many volunteers are available to count them each year.

Wassberg said he didnโ€™t approve of any city efforts to address homelessness and made disparaging remarks about homeless people, claiming โ€œall they do is drugs and alcohol.โ€ However, he also said during the forum that he himself was once homeless and lived out of his truck for 16 years.

Brown praised the planned opening of Motel 6 on 24th Street as permanent supportive affordable housing but wants more to be done.

โ€œCan we do more to address homelessness?โ€ Brown said. โ€œYes we can. But we have to have aggressive leadership on council who will push the issue.โ€

She said she often sees homeless people sleeping outside the gates of two large empty lots at 12th street and Macdonald Avenue, and asked why supportive housing couldnโ€™t be built there.

โ€œLetโ€™s start utilizing those underused spaces throughout Richmond,โ€ Brown said.

Skepticism around โ€˜Green-Blue New Dealโ€

All candidates were skeptical of current city leadershipโ€™s plans related to the environment, including the Green-Blue New Deal, which aims to provide careers for residents in renewable energy, electrification and efficiency, sustainable transportation, zero waste, water, and land use. They also were skeptical about other local efforts to harness renewable energy, such as installing wind turbines.

Wassberg called the plan โ€œnothing but a scam,โ€ saying that people โ€œwill never be able to get over fossil fuels,โ€ and that ending reliance on fossil fuels would โ€œcause chaos.โ€

Anderson called the plan โ€œa bunch of fat air,โ€ because it hasnโ€™t been practically achievable. He pointed out that two companies that had been offering Green-Blue New Deal jobs, solar battery companies SunPower and Moxion, left the project as they filed for bankruptcy. 

Installing wind turbines to harness renewable wind energy, Anderson said, wouldnโ€™t be achievable because theyโ€™d likely have to be installed in or near Point Richmond, and its residents wouldnโ€™t want to look at them. He also expressed doubts that the Bay Area Coastal Commission and the Coast Guard would allow their construction off-shore, as has been suggested.

Dunning said that he supports transiting from fossil fuels to renewable energy in principle, but โ€œyou donโ€™t do it just by saying it.โ€

Citing a conversation he had with a person who works on a government commission who helps decide where wind turbines can go, Dunning said that Richmondโ€™s location is not currently appropriate for installing wind turbines now or in the near future. 

โ€œThese things take decades to assess,โ€ Dunning said. โ€œTheyโ€™re not going to be here anytime soon.โ€

Brown said she agreed with Dunning, and added that she thinks the city โ€œis so focused on being progressive that weโ€™re not making informed decisions.โ€

While not directly addressing any environmental issues, Brown said, โ€œWeโ€™re not considering what the experts are suggesting, and weโ€™re leaving the city behind.โ€

In her closing statement, Brown doubled down on her criticism of current city leadership.

โ€œWe know that there is monotony on the city council and that there is a supermajority that we need to break up,โ€ she said. โ€œLetโ€™s get District 1 and the city of Richmond back on track.โ€

Dunning spoke about how more diverse opinions need to be represented on the city council.

โ€œIf you want to find a breakthrough solution thatโ€™s never been found before, youโ€™re never going to get it from one way of looking at things,โ€ Dunning said.

Wassberg and Anderson both specifically criticized the Richmond Progressive Alliance. Mayor Eduardo Martinez and four out of six of Richmondโ€™s council members are part of the alliance, and they generally vote together.

โ€œWe need to get the RPA out,โ€ Wassberg said. โ€œAs long as the RPA is in office, itโ€™s just going to be the same garbage over and over.โ€

Anderson said that the Richmond Progressive Alliance came into power by demanding that Chevron and large corporations stop influencing Richmond politics, but that alliance members recently โ€œgot paid by Chevron.โ€

While the city did just accept the $550 settlement from Chevron, RPA members have not accepted campaign donations from the oil company.

Anderson accused RPA members of โ€œbecoming the status quoโ€ and said that โ€œdiversity of thought is important to energize and motivate the community.โ€


Criticizing current leadership and uplifting other candidates at the forum, Anderson closed the event by saying, โ€œWe don’t have that safe harbor that keeps us focused on the goal. Iโ€™m offering that and many of us here are offering that.

Join the Conversation

2 Comments

  1. How insulting for anyone to suggest that moderator Robert Rogers, of John Gioiaโ€™s office, was biased in any way. If anything would have been unfair about this forum, it would have come from the questions asked. Certainly, he was as fair and professional as any candidate on any side could ever hope for. Itโ€™s a shame that the RPA candidates chose not to participate.

  2. I wonder if the RPA mayor and council will put action behind their “words” about smoke shops? ” Mayor Eduardo Martinez said that 78 licensed smoke shops were operating, but that additional ones were operating without a license.”

    The “action” should be to immediately shut down any smoke shop operating without a permit. Tag the business. Assess the fines for an unpermitted business as our city codes provide, and do it today. Report unpermitted business to the state tax board.

Leave a comment
Richmondside welcomes thoughtful and relevant discussion on this content. Please review our comments policy before posting a comment. Thanks!

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *